Gerrard never in top 3, but very close Scholes nowhere near top 3 Highest Ballon D'or Finish Lampard 2nd - one time Gerrard 3rd - one time Scholes nowhere near top 3 Premier League Team of the Year Appearances Gerrard 8 Lampard 5 Scholes 2 Premier League Player of the Month Awards Gerrard 6 Lampard 4 Scholes 4 Born and bred in Manchester, Paul Scholes is one of the most recognized and celebrated players from Manchester United most successful period in history. Can't decide between sheffield university and Warwick Unviersity??? Regardless of who you think the best player amongst these three is, I think we can all agree that the fact that Scholes never received a single vote is a bit odd. Comparatively, Lampard and Gerrard played their last season in England at 36 and 35 years of age and both never produced higher than an 85% pass completion rate in any season throughout their entire careers. Honours & Awards. Subsequently, all three were understandably also moved deeper and deeper towards the end of their careers. Absolutely. Today, however, we are here to discuss three particular players who were part of this golden generation and who are frequently compared to one another. That Arsene Wengers legendary Arsenal sides made special plans to stop Scholes prior to matches against United says everything about how dangerous and effective the midfielder was. In fact, Scholes has received the most Ballon d'Or nominations without ever receiving a single vote (5) per Football 365. License () - CC BY 2.02. I have to go with Paul Scholes, and I love Stevie G. Paul Scholes was just ahead in his head. During an appearance on Sky Sports Monday Night Football in 2019, however, Henry caused a stir on social media with his opinion on the Scholes vs Gerrard debate. This is a measure of which player was able to best adapt their playing style and position over the course of their career. Toni Kroos believes Paul Scholes was a superior midfielder than Steven Gerrard and Frank Lampard as he handed down his verdict on one of football's hotly debated topics. It's not the first time Scholes, Lampard and Gerrard have been the subject of fierce debate. Topics:.css-wpf514{color:#72B97D;}Frank Lampard, Liverpool, Paul Scholes, Football News, Chelsea, Football, Manchester United, Ballon d'Or, Steven Gerrard, Ryan Reynolds and Rob McElhenney confirm they are serious about signing Gareth Bale for Wrexham, Real Madrid in pursuit of Man Utd's Alejandro Garnacho with deal deemed 'very manageable', Perfect for Liverpool - Robbie Fowler urges Jurgen Klopp told to sign Newcastle's Joelinton, Jordan Pickford hilariously celebrates penalty save to deny James Maddison, fans are all saying the same thing, Sky Sports have spoken to Martin Tyler over Heung-Min Son comment he made in Liverpool vs Spurs commentary, BREAKING: Graeme Souness leaves Sky Sports after 15 years as a pundit, Virgil van Dijk had his left ankle and entire reputation shattered by Ivan Perisic's run, Steven Gerrard was 'on another planet' to Paul Scholes and Frank Lampard, Sven Goran Eriksson Settles Steven Gerrard, Frank Lampard Or Paul Scholes Debate, Pep Guardiola picks Paul Scholes in the classic 'Gerrard, Lampard or Scholes' debate, Comparing Steven Gerrard, Frank Lampard And Paul Scholes By Their Career Ballon d'Or Votes. Football fans reckon Roy Keane has settled the age old Steven Gerrard, Frank Lampard or Paul Scholes debate. No use with unauthorized audio, video, data, fixture lists, club/league logos or live services. He has been captain of Liverpool since 2003, and has guided them to an FA Cup, a League Cup and a Champions League since then. Scholes probably gets the hipster choice, and became more popular as he got older as he was less of a sexy star player than Lampard or Gerrard and his style of play evolved as the Man U tactical system evolved with the input from Quiroz. Not to mention that theyve both won 2 English player of the year awards and one football writers association award each. As previously stated, this is a measure of who was able to adapt better over the course of their career. Ive always been interested in the game and tried to learn as much as I can about how it all works on and off the pitch. Forget statistics, we're answering this question for you. I think Stevie G comes really close to him but Paul Scholes would have to win., After Carragher gave him some stick for picking Scholes over his mate Gerrard, Henry held his hands up and said: Im just saying! Sven-Goran Eriksson was unable to fit all three into the same side, often resulting in criticism from supporters when one of them was left out. Stevie G is widely regarded as not only the best captain, but also the best player in Liverpool history. Every time we were playing them, we needed to find a way to stop him. Each players was born within 6 years of one another, Each spent almost the entirety of their career at one club, These clubs happen to be each others rivals, they each retired within three years of one another, and finally, they have all predominantly played in central midfield positions throughout their careers. Adding onto that, he was one of the greatest leaders of all time. He is also one of two midfielders to feature in the top 20 goal scorers of all time in the competition. Scholes played for the most successful team in the country for two decades. Even Lampard's second highest assists tally in a Premier League campaign - 14 during 2009/10 - is enough to eclipse his former England colleagues. The Irishman appeared on Sky Sports' flagship show for Manchester United's home match against Brentford on Monday night, where he was asked to name his ultimate Red Devils XI of the Premier League era. Posted below is a head-to-head comparison of Scholes and Gerrard's stats in FIFA 20. Not on the pl when football started of course 80s Robson was incredible.". This means that we may include adverts from us and third parties based on our knowledge of you. Source () - https://www.soccer.ru/galery/1076300/photo/7577565. Matches, Goals, Assists, Yellow Cards, Red Cards, Playing Time, Awards, Trophy \u0026 More. Theyve both won multiple player of the month awards throughout their careers. Answer: Steven Gerrard Admittedly, there's no universally-agreed way to decide which accolades should count here, but Gerrard takes the win by our calculations with at least 50 individual. Yes, we're delving into one of football's age old questions - who's the greatest midfielder between Scholes, Lampard and Gerrard? However, they also gain experience and in game intelligence, this allows them to conserve their energy for when it is needed and still remain effective. Surprisingly, Keane opted for a midfield two of Paul Ince and Bryan Robson, omitting Scholes from the team entirely. Another big win for Lampard who astonishingly bagged 27 goals from midfield in 2009/10 on his way to a third Premier League crown at Stamford Bridge. Copyright The Student Room 2023 all rights reserved. He obviously did not accomplish these victories single handedly, but his influence cannot be understated here. The three former midfielders have been retired for several years but are still often compared by football fans today. Meanwhile, another stat-by-stat battle compared United legend Nemanja Vidic against Liverpool star Virgil van Dijk. Its always interesting hearing everyones take on these legends. And SPORTbible has now decided to use Futhead to do a side-by-side comparison of Scholes and Gerrard's in-game stats in FIFA 20. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. He began his professional career with Liverpool in 1998. And realistically, this argument can go either way. He truly was a generational talent, winning a multitude of club and personal awards during a time where Liverpool frequently failed to perform in the premier league. Seeing as all three of these players started their careers in the early to mid-90s, comparing them from a statistical point of view, with the data available, doesnt yield a concrete outcome. Regardless of what the statistics might say or how the discourse on Twitter might unfold, the ballers who know, know. Comparatively, Lampard and Gerrard played their last season in England at 36 and 35 years of age and both never produced higher than an 85% pass completion rate in any season throughout their entire careers. If Im being completely honest, before even beginning any research for this category, I was convinced that Frank Lampard would be head and shoulders above the other two in terms of personal achievements. Instead, he was deployed in several different positions before he was eventually recognized as a being more effective in the middle of the park. Both Lampard and Scholes have scored three times for England away from qualifiers and friendlies, but we're giving second place to the latter for doing so across three separate tournaments. As a former world-class midfielder himself who is more than aware of English footballing . Paul Scholes and Steven Gerrard have been placed in a head-to-head FIFA 20 stat comparison battle to determine who holds the better overall attributes. "Them two were amazing, amazing players. "I'm sick to death of hearing about this, to be honest. Something went wrong, please try again later. It's pretty surprising to learn that Scholes and Lampard were only named in the TOTY twice and three times respectively, leaving them well short of Gerrard's staggering record of eight(!?) It's a debate that has raged for well over two decades: Paul Scholes, Steven Gerrard or Frank Lampard? License () - CC BY-SA 3.02. Once Guardiola had clarified that Ferdinand was asking who he thought was best, the City coach instantly responded: "All respect to Frank [Lampard], to Steven [Gerrard] but Paul Scholes is my favourite one. Premier League 10 Seasons Awards (1992-93 to 2001-02): Domestic & Overall Team of the Decade English Football Hall of Fame Inductee: 2008 Gerrard ****s all over Scholes. It's a very, very convincing win for Lampard who racked up 18 assists during Chelsea's 2004-05 title-winning season, whereas Gerrard's best came in 2013/14 with 13 assists and Scholes peaked with seven in 1998/99. The Liverpool legend received 220 votes throughout his career, with the Chelsea hero recording 169 votes while the United icon failed to pick up a single vote during his storied playing days.. Who's the best? I mean, the guy scored 22 goals and made 14 assists in 2010, as a midfielder. He began his professional playing career with United in 1993. Lets not even bring Chelsea legend Frank Lampard into the discussion for now. Steven Gerrard is the only player amongst these three that was ever the official captain of their team. To make sure you never miss out on your favourite NEW stories, we're happy to send you some reminders, Click 'OK' then 'Allow' to enable notifications, .css-1diosym{color:black;}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){.css-1diosym{color:#fff;}}Published17:07,27 November 2020 GMT.css-7su1ft{color:#666666;}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){.css-7su1ft{color:#72B97D;}}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-7su1ft{color:#666666;}}| Last updated17:17,27 November 2020 GMT. All of these players were deployed as box to box midfielders, dynamic number 8s, attacking midfielders and much much more at varying points in their careers. Therefore, this category has to go to Paul Scholes. Premier League 20 Seasons Awards (1992-93 to 2011-12): Most Player Appearances (596) UEFA Champions League 10 Seasons Dream Team (1992 to 2002): 2002 Wales Player of the Year Award (2): 1996, 2006 Premier League Player of the Month (3): September 1993, August 2006, February 2007 English Football Hall of Fame Inductee: 2005 Unfortunately, as stated on the Premier League website, the majority of these stats were only recorded comprehensively starting from 2006 onwards. Gerrard clear of all. The average rating across Scholes' three ICON cards comes to 89, which is enough to oust Gerrard on 88.6 and Lampard with 88. After an injury to Roy Keane in 1997, Scholes was moved into the central midfield position where he spent the remainder of his career. In all seriousness, despite the similarities noted in this write-up, I just want to reiterate that each player fulfilled vastly different roles in their clubs, at their respective peaks. There are a host of debates in football which will probably never . Now bringing the focus of this thought back to Scholes, Gerrard and Lampard. Lampard began his career, in 1995, with West Ham United. The final criteria is understandably more subjective than the other two. So, heres how this assessment is going to work; Six separate categories will be used to compare each of these three players. To give you an idea of how prolific this man was throughout his career. Gerrard comes second with a ratio of 4.07 and then Scholes on 4.64. Pep Guardiola is pretty well placed to answer the Paul Scholes vs Steven Gerrard vs Frank Lampard debate. When you look into the similarities between these three individuals, based on their playing careers, its easy to see why the comparisons are so prevalent. A childhood obsession for all things football developed into a career writing about the beautiful game. And, right off the bat, its worth noting that although they share many similarities, all three of these players had different responsibilities within their respective teams, this makes it difficult to compare them. He was making Man United tick. 3. But very different players. Incredible. What are the most competative courses at Cardiff university? And to Guardiola's credit, he didn't shy away from making his feelings clear when the question was put to him by Rio Ferdinand during an interview at the back end of 2022. Besides, it's a conversation that pulls in some of the biggest fanbases across the land with each player holding legendary status at Manchester United, Liverpool and Chelsea respectively. He wins 3 of the 6 criteria, with Lampard in second place with 2, and Gerrard in third place with 1. The Scholes, Lampard or Gerrard debate has raged for over 20 years, with fans split not just on who the greatest midfielder of them all was but also which combination of the two performed better for England. Official: Aston University A100 2023 Entry Applicant and Offer Holder thread, 2023 Oxbridge Anthropology Postgraduate Application. It might come as a surprise to learn that none of the three players ever reached double figures and that Gerrard's pretty average-looking tally of seven set-piece goals gives him the victory. His overall understanding of the game allowed him to dictate the pace of each match in a way that is still yet to be matched in the Premier League. ", Scholes broke his silence on the debate involving himself, Gerrard and Lampard back in May by saying he is "sick to death of hearing about this.". Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We'll openly admitted that the data is hard to come by in this department, but Transfermarkt attributes 23 international assists to Gerrard, which is more than the 12 and 10 put on Lampard and Scholes' names. This site uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. Yet another generational talent that is widely considered to be the best player in the history of his club. Source () - Cropped and lightened version of the file uploaded to Flickr with the name scholsey5. Author () - Austin Osuide4. ", Who was better: Scholes, Lampard or Gerrard? . All three played football professionally for roughly two decades, so this is essentially an assessment on how effective they were able to remain, despite the natural evolution of the game over time. Just as an aside note, I will only be considering their playing careers within the English Premier League. Similar to Scholes, Gerrard did not play in the central midfield position from the offset of his career. It also makes a mockery of claims that Scholes was, in fact, overrated. Gerrard, Scholes and Lampard have been frequently compared by fans as they attempt to settle who was the best out of the trio.